Whitefish Bay WI Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Unbeatable location in the heart of Whitefish Bay, this home has been masterfully renovated to blend modern sophistication with timeless charm. Step inside to find a stunning kitchen featuring a large center island, generous dining room perfect for hosting dinner parties and a spacious living room, complete with a cozy fireplace. You'll also appreciate the convenience of a 1st-floor office & dedicated mud/laundry room, designed for today's busy lifestyles. Upstairs, the home features 4 generously sized bedrooms & 3 bathrooms, including a luxurious primary ensuite with 2 walk-in closets & 2nd guest ensuite. The large backyard creates an inviting oasis & the attached, heated 2.5-car garage adds practicality. Best of all, this gem is situated just 1 block from Lake Michigan & Big Bay Park.

Welcome to cheerful and move-in ready! This bright and happy home is nicely updated in all the right places. Features renovated, open kitchen with new cabinets, quartz counters, and stainless appliances. Living room with east-facing windows glows with sunlight. A sweet 3-season room is great for morning coffee or bird watching. Upstairs includes three, nice-sized BRs and a beautifully remodeled bathroom with tiled shower and stylish vanity. The finished LL is a great place to relax, enjoy movies, or favorite hobbies. The huge backyard is a rare find with lots of space for raised gardens, playsets, and outdoor fun. Love to bike or take long walks? The Oak Leaf Trail is practically in your backyard. Enjoy soccer fields, disc golf, beer garden, and a fenced dog park at nearby Estabrook Park!

Design Your Dream Home in Whitefish Bay! Looking for a fantastic opportunity to create a home that's truly your own? This semi-demo'd gem is ready for transformation sitting on a coveted block in Whitefish Bay, just steps from Silver Spring shops, top-rated schools, and Klode Park. The interior space is primed for finishing, with the bathrooms, kitchen, and family room ready for design. Work within the existing footprint or expand, using the available architectural plans to bring your vision to life. New furnace installed giving you one less thing to worry about. Whether you envision a cozy modern haven or a spacious entertainer's paradise, this property is a blank canvas for your creativity. Let's talk about making this house your custom dream home

Full of charm & character, this sweet Whitefish Bay bungalow will have you at hello! Gleaming hardwood floors greet you as you enter & welcome you into a lovely living room with natural fireplace. The coved ceilings & built-in cabinetry continue in the dining room & lead to a beautiful, updated kitchen with farmhouse sink, granite countertops & newer stainless steel appliances. Two bedrooms & fabulous full bath round out the 1st floor. Upstairs, find a generous primary bedroom with walk-in closet & an updated 2nd full bath. The lower level offers fantastic rec room space, room for a gym or office, laundry & storage as well. Outside, stamped concrete front walk leads you to a charming front porch & the fully-fenced backyard features fantastic patio, perfect for enjoying time outside.

Stunning 4-Bdrm, 2.5-Bath Home in the heart of the Bay. This beautifully renovated home, completed in 2018, offers the perfect blend of modern style & classic charm. Step inside to discover an open, light-filled living space w/stylish KIT open to FR. The LR & DR are perfect for both relaxing & entertaining, w/gorgeous HWFs. A butler's pantry & mudroom are additional highlights. Upstairs features primary w/luxurious en-suite bath. 3 addtl bdrms offer plenty of space for family, guests, or home office. And don't miss the loft off the 4th bdrm! Located just steps from shops, restaurants, & schools, this home offers both convenience & charm. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own a beautifully updated home in a prime location!

Exceptional opportunity to own a custom home in the heart of Whitefish Bay, set for completion in August 2025! Designed by renowned KCB Architects, this residence offers impeccable craftsmanship, modern amenities, and a spacious layout for luxurious living. The open-concept first floor features a gourmet kitchen with a scullery, a sunlit great room with a gas fireplace, a flexible guest suite or office, and an attached two-car garage. The second level includes a serene primary suite, additional bedrooms, and a private rooftop terrace. The finished lower level boasts a media room, game room, exercise space, sauna, and cold plunge tub. Located near shops, cafes, schools, and parks. Photos are virtual renderings. Contact for more details.

Modern living at its finest in warm & inviting colonial in sought-after Whitefish Bay! The bright living room features hardwood floors, a picture window, & neutral tones. Host in the spacious dining room with built-in china cabinets, crown molding, and chair rail detail. The cozy family room opens to a fabulous deck and fenced backyard. The kitchen offers a built-in dinette, granite countertops, and ample storage. Upstairs, find generous bedrooms with newer carpet and ceiling fans. Updated baths. The lower level includes a versatile office/flex space along with laundry/storage area. New windows throughout. Conveniently close to I-43 and just minutes from downtown Milwaukee. Enjoy walkability to top-rated schools, restaurants, shopping, the Interurban Trail, and Estabrook Park Biergarten!

Welcome home to one of the most idyllic communities. Take a short stroll to Lake Michigan through charming Klode Park, or walk to some of the top rated schools in the state, and the quaint shops of Whitefish Bay from your new home with updates galore. This sun-drenched colonial with newer windows, roof, and mechanicals offers formal spaces and open concept for quiet nights or holiday gatherings. Kitchen with newer quartzite counters and stainless steel appliances opens to the spacious great room with cute dinette area and natural fireplace. The primary suite is a wonderful retreat w/vaulted ceiling, walk-in closet, and private bath. 2nd updated bath and 3 spacious bedrooms complete the upper, while finished lower offers flex space for family room and office, gym or playroom. Just move in!

Elegant and livable Lake Drive colonial! Sunny Living room has a dramatic barrel ceiling and fireplace; adjacent sunroom is an ideal office or den. Oversized dining room leads to a classic white kitchen with comfortable and casual breakfast nook. Spacious family room rounds out the main level living spaces and leads to a private fenced yard with patio. 4 upstairs bedrooms provide a peaceful retreat. You'll love the updated bath and walk in closet at the primary. Lower level family room is the perfect place to gather and play. Thoughtful details abound - tasteful decor, hardwood floors, crown molding, and custom cabinetry. Whitefish Bay Schools, near Klode Park, and convenient to shops, restaurants and fun! This gem is ready for you. Welcome home!

They don't build homes like this anymore! Stunning, old world details in this WFBay home! Step down into the large living room with quarter sawn beautiful wood floors and lovely fireplace. Gorgeous leaded and stained glass windows flood the home with light. Beautiful new eat in kitchen with high end appliances. Formal dining room and pretty sunroom that looks out onto the tastefully hardscaped and landscaped yard. Ensuite, large primary and two other bedrooms with additional full bath. One of the rooms is quite large with sitting room. 3rd floor bedroom and half bath. Finished lower level with fireplace and full bath. FABULOUS block minutes from downtown and all the shops and schools of WFBay.

Opportunity knocks for an enterprising buyer. Charming 1924 bungalow offers a great opportunity to exercise your vision. Features a spacious kitchen, first floor bedroom/den and full bathroom. Keep as-is or reimagine into a modern open plan. Upstairs includes a primary bedroom with large walk-in closet a full bath with large tub and standing shower. Three additional bedrooms complete the upstairs. The exceptionally large lot is where the magic awaits. Features a magnificently cultivated bee and butterfly garden. Feeling ambitious? The oversized lot can accommodate the grand addition of your dreams. Conveniently located near Cahill Park, Cumberland elementary school and Whitefish Bay middle and high schools.

Stunning Colonial in the heart of Cumberland Forest with an easy walk to all Whitefish Bay Schools, the Village's entertainment district, and Lake Michigan. Newly refinished hardwood floors, freshly painted interiors, tall ceilings and beautiful moldings throughout. Two story addition offers open concept kitchen with island and cool slate floors, family room with stone fireplace, wet bar and French doors to backyard. Spacious living room with second fireplace and formal dining room with built-ins. Upstairs primary suite has dual walk-in closets, panoramic views of the backyard through wall of windows, window seat, and en suite with walk in shower and dual sinks. Addition features full Lower Level with third fireplace, full bath, room for 5th bedroom and office space. 2.5 Car Garage

Completely renovated and full of charm, this stunning cottage in the heart of the bay blends modern comfort with classic character! Featuring a sun-filled open concept living space with refinished hardwoods and stylish finishes, this home offers a cozy yet open feel. The updated kitchen boasts white shaker cabinetry, stainless appliances and quartz countertops. Upstairs, find a unique loft space with skylights, offering a perfect retreat. The renovated bathroom offers a deep soaking tub and ceramic tile surround. The lower level features the third bedroom, rec room and laundry. Outside you'll find a gorgeous three season room and a large partially fenced yard. Brand new windows, exterior doors, central air, fresh paint inside and out and all new lighting add to this perfect package!

This stunning new construction home in Whitefish Bay offers 5 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms, thoughtfully designed with high-quality finishes and modern conveniences. The main level boasts 9-foot ceilings, a gourmet kitchen featuring custom cabinetry, quartzite countertops, and top-of-the-line Thermador appliances, perfect for entertaining. Marvin Elevate windows and doors flood the space with natural light. The heated attached garage ensures comfort year-round. Upstairs, enjoy two luxurious en-suites with heated floors, including a primary suite with a spa-like bath and spacious walk-in closet. Smart-home technology adds seamless functionality to this exceptional home!

Discover this spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom home in the heart of Whitefish Bay, offering an exceptional layout and prime location near all the amenities you need! Recent updates include a dimensional shingle roof, upgraded kitchen cabinets, durable Pergo flooring, and newer windows. With flexible living space, this home provides 5-6 bedrooms or options for an office or nursery, perfect for your lifestyle needs. Nestled on one of the neighborhood's largest double-wide lots, the property features a beautifully remodeled kitchen, a generous dining area, and gleaming hardwood floors throughout. The expansive backyarda rare find in Whitefish Bayoffers endless opportunities for outdoor enjoyment. This home is truly a blend of comfort, style, and unbeatable convenience!

MULTIPLE OFFERS-REVIEWING 2PM SUNDAY. WHITEFISH BAY! Move right in to this meticulously maintained 1,107 square foot two-bedroom ranch. Enter through the bright sunroom, and then fall in love with the living room's natural fireplace and hardwood floors. The formal dining room leads to an updated kitchen. The full basement features workshop areas, high ceilings, and is BEGGING TO BE FINISHED. Outside is a rare double lot that's fenced, with beautiful landscaping by a professional botanist. You'll be within walking distance of all Whitefish Bay schools, the shops & restaurants on Oakland Ave, and Big Bay Beach on Lake Michigan. Easy access to I-43 just 1.5 miles west on Hampton. Life in The Bay is a dream come true.

This charming Lannon Stone Cape Cod in Whitefish Bay features rich hardwood floors and formal living room with natural fireplace. The bright kitchen, with quartz counters and stainless appliances, opens to a family room, while the formal dining room has character rich details like a built-in china cabinet and chair rail. The newly remodeled first-floor bath includes a custom-tiled walk-in shower and Kohler fixtures. A spacious breezeway adds extra space for a mudroom and leads to a quiet, back patio. With three generous bedrooms, a finished lower-level rec room, and a fully floored attic for potential expansion, this updated home offers plenty of space for the ones you love. Move in, relax, and enjoy the holidays!

Nestled on a picturesque tree-lined street, this charming 1930s Tudor home exudes timeless elegance. Its striking half-timbered facade and steeply pitched roof are complemented by arched doorways and leaded glass windows, inviting warmth and character. Inside, vintage details aboundoriginal hardwood floors, intricately carved moldings, and a cozy fireplace serve as focal points in the inviting living spaces. The spacious dining room features a built-in China cabinet, perfect for displaying heirloom pieces. Sunlight streams through large leaded-glass windows. A quaint kitchen leads to an outdoor patio. Surrounded by majestic trees, this home captures the essence of a bygone era making it a true gem in the heart of the neighborhood.

Welcome to the first sale of this custom Mid-century timecapsule by architect Richard E. Oberst. From the moment you step inside you will be WOWED by light shining thru 24 ft of living rm windows that draw your eyes outside. The Tenn Crab Orchard Stone exterior is also found inside at the impressive fireplace and planter. XL LR w/ vaulted white oak paneled ceiling casts a warm glow. Excellent layout includes: main flr primary w/ ensuite, swanky paneled FR w/ hwf, DR, 3 season room, lrg kitchen, main flr laundry & half ba. Upstairs there's 4 more bedrms & full ba. Massive LL w/ half ba is primed for finishing. Desireable Cumberland Forest area. Nice sized yard. Att 2 car garage. This one-of-a-kind home is waiting for new owners to preserve or take it to the next level!

Welcome home to this spacious and impeccably maintained condo in the heart of Whitefish Bay. Incredible value with numerous updates including entire interior freshly painted (2025), carpets professionally cleaned (2024), new water heater (2023) and new AC units (2022). Featuring an eat-in kitchen, open concept living/dining and a private balcony. Underground parking space and storage unit included. Why rent when you can own? Don't miss this opportunity to make this condo your own and start building instant equity!

Beautiful Bungalow located in the heart of Whitefish Bay with fabulous walkability to Shorewood's business district. This property boasts two remodeled bathrooms and a remodeled kitchen. Three bedrooms, plus an enclosed flex space rounds out this home. Whitefish Bay and Shorewood Village District lines divides this property's backyard, allowing Buyer to choose their preference of school district.

Discover the elegance of this refined Tudor home, ideally situated on a beautiful boulevard. Meticulously updated w/an architect-designed addition, this residence offers a harmonious blend of classic charm and modern luxury. Featuring 4 generously sized bedrooms and 2.5 baths, the home is perfect for both relaxation and entertaining. The inviting living and formal dining room exude sophistication, while the 1st floor office provides a versatile space for work/study. The gourmet kitchen opens to a spacious family room, which flows through doors to a private patio, ideal for outdoor living. A large lot offers extensive green space beyond the 2.5 car garage. With two natural fireplaces and ample storage throughout, this home provides both comfort & convenience in a truly exceptional setting.

Bight and sunny colonial in a great WFB location. Hardwood floors greet you as you enter the home. Remodeled kitchen features vaulted ceiling and large eat-in. Family room off the kitchen with built in cabinetry. Upstairs are 3 bedroons, including a great primary suite with updated bath and walk in closet. Charming backyard with new 2 car garage! Private patio and fenced in yard makes for great entertaining. Lower level rec room for additional space. Move right in and let the sun shine in!